{
  "visual_id": "V23",
  "title": "Core differences need not imply large wind-cooling differences",
  "classification": "new_simulation",
  "status": "validated_within_scope",
  "experiment_ids": [
    "E19-cooling"
  ],
  "run_ids": [
    "20260927T161038868296Z-E19-cooling"
  ],
  "model_ids": [
    "M3-ordinary-physics-element-resolved-enrichment-control"
  ],
  "claim_ids": [
    "C03",
    "C10"
  ],
  "input_files": [
    {
      "path": "runs/20260927T161038868296Z-E19-cooling/same-metallicity-cooling.csv",
      "sha256": "e4e9ea6098494d165ad4e62b5e7f446aced5c75479408cfc0ad052cb5d606360"
    },
    {
      "path": "runs/20260927T161038868296Z-E19-cooling/cloud-baseline-1e-05.npz",
      "sha256": "07db8414ae5edf756ec3751a23c76dd37e1693ab8ff4a62bf0fc836e741f14cc"
    },
    {
      "path": "runs/20260927T161038868296Z-E19-cooling/cloud-Hoyle-plus-1e-05.npz",
      "sha256": "8e14314968b5dec319875b5b258fdcd232ff6c602bfceedd302ebf3a43e9e0f8"
    },
    {
      "path": "runs/20260927T161038868296Z-E19-cooling/cloud-Hoyle-minus-1e-05.npz",
      "sha256": "41bdc1b5cfe40c3e84c9a13478f5d43533e273c9c43fdc8629f6357cc18c5e83"
    },
    {
      "path": "runs/20260927T161038868296Z-E19-cooling/cloud-C-poor-control-1e-05.npz",
      "sha256": "d693ef4e6917391e9edd9df7cc77b9da7b1bec49097f191824f66e3e4fa8200b"
    },
    {
      "path": "runs/20260927T161038868296Z-E19-cooling/cloud-C-rich-control-1e-05.npz",
      "sha256": "471ca956de0c33bba461060fbe782fa1073f541431d8d3437ba05257601022e0"
    }
  ],
  "plotted_values": {
    "path": "V23-data.json",
    "sha256": "f41b77f541ade2121ebe83d41b572e3f7b3f0a3a6418dde9f080332d97ca6487"
  },
  "source_ids": [
    "E19-carbon-cooling",
    "E19-LAMDA-Cplus",
    "E19-LAMDA-O"
  ],
  "units": "Explicit axis labels and unit-bearing source columns; normalized quantities are defined in the caption.",
  "transformations": [
    "Saved numerical outputs only; physical interpolation, selection and normalization are described by the generator and caption."
  ],
  "uncertainty_type": "Numerical controls, published errors, and declared model/nuisance scenarios remain distinct; no biological threshold.",
  "validity_limits": [
    "A component calculation does not establish an observationally allowed complete history."
  ],
  "caption": "Same total metal fraction Z=10\u207b\u2075, with 70% of metals assigned to C+O. Actual wind patterns nearly overlap; deliberately carbon-poor/rich controls probe a much broader contrast. Left: fixed 200 K cooling diagnostic. Right: one-zone compression/cooling, stopped at the first validity limit when reached. These calculations omit molecular/dust cooling and resolved hydrodynamics, and predict neither fragmentation nor a stellar mass distribution.",
  "alt_text": "Actual stellar wind composition curves nearly overlap at fixed metallicity. Strong declared carbon/oxygen redistribution has a larger effect on cooling and temperature trajectories.",
  "render_command": "uv run --offline --frozen python run.py full render",
  "generator_sha256": "fa75ece843491c857348bd38d22cfeeae732a8bb9caa8c1921182f783c2cc6a4",
  "extension_generator_sha256": "4cef7f7e2f45594db1c8eb981fb50ae736aad43e6708d1f12826d99b57a40cce",
  "output_sha256": {
    "svg": "e3920d53cd3f992525551173d12d91a623641a985463efa24983a56e6db0dfcb",
    "png": "4707266f78942c91db08dca22c5b859f5d8ecaacec04a3f63b06b841785a9d44"
  }
}