{ "schema_version": 1, "prepared_on": "2026-09-24", "note": "Full computational campaign. Run validation establishes the declared component scope, not the entire scientific claim. The immutable handoff and earlier pilot ledgers are preserved.", "claims": [ { "id": "C01", "statement": "A specified theory can contain persistent field configurations with distinct effective particle properties.", "status": "classical_components_validated_physical_history_unresolved", "scope": "Distinct classical backgrounds and a coupled tunneling solution are independently reproduced. Their existence does not establish an occupied, observationally allowed cosmic phase.", "evidence": [ "runs/20260927T064011591343Z-E05-E06-fields/manifest.json", "runs/20260927T140828510865Z-E06-coupled-modes/manifest.json" ], "sources": [ "S14", "S17", "S19", "S20" ], "experiments": [ "E00", "E05", "E06" ], "strengthen": "Independently reproduce distinct minima and a valid transition in the same matched effective theory; verify that observable dimensionless couplings differ.", "weaken": "Minima fail stability checks, are physically equivalent, or disappear within relevant corrections; report exclusion only for that model.", "new_run_ids": [ "20260927T064011591343Z-E05-E06-fields", "20260927T140828510865Z-E06-coupled-modes" ], "new_computations_in_this_handoff": false, "permitted_article_language": "Distinct classical backgrounds and a coupled tunneling solution are independently reproduced. Their existence does not establish an occupied, observationally allowed cosmic phase.", "inherited_status": "constructed_in_inherited_classical_toy_model", "new_computations_in_campaign": true }, { "id": "C02", "statement": "Changes in fundamental parameters can change the Hoyle threshold and helium-burning reaction rates.", "status": "evaluated_threshold_and_conditional_capture_response_computed", "scope": "Published local Hoyle responses and complete modeled ground-state capture amplitudes give nuclear sensitivity. Missing matched nuclear derivatives and a published coefficient ambiguity limit the alternative-phase prediction.", "evidence": [ "runs/20260927T062341249451Z-E01-evaluated/manifest.json", "runs/20260927T061740090093Z-E02-full/manifest.json", "runs/20260927T130334139769Z-E02-EXFOR/manifest.json" ], "sources": [ "S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06" ], "experiments": [ "E01", "E02", "E05" ], "strengthen": "Reproduce evaluated baseline nuclear data and the published responses; calculate complete thermal rates with consistent energy levels and covariance where available.", "weaken": "Correlated threshold changes suppress the claimed response, reverse its sign, or make its magnitude indeterminate under allowed nuclear uncertainties.", "new_run_ids": [ "20260927T062341249451Z-E01-evaluated", "20260927T061740090093Z-E02-full", "20260927T130334139769Z-E02-EXFOR" ], "new_computations_in_this_handoff": false, "permitted_article_language": "Published local Hoyle responses and complete modeled ground-state capture amplitudes give nuclear sensitivity. Missing matched nuclear derivatives and a published coefficient ambiguity limit the alternative-phase prediction.", "inherited_status": "published_model_dependent_response_available", "new_computations_in_campaign": true, "next_phase_evidence": { "run_ids": [ "20260929T000630939629Z-E02-source-audit", "20260929T000630827264Z-E15-source-audit", "20260929T001131960631Z-E18-charged-controls" ], "report": "reports/next-phase-findings.md", "scope": "Additional diagnostics and gates; no upgrade to an observed or integrated claim." }, "buildout_evidence": { "run_ids": [ "20260929T004604528575Z-P1-precision", "20260929T011446478595Z-E18-matrix-controls" ], "report": "reports/buildout-findings.md", "scope": "Scoped controls/non-identifiability, not a detected or viable integrated model." }, "experiment_evidence": { "run_ids": [ "20260929T024206209567Z-P1-renormalized", "20260929T023727021282Z-E18-halo" ], "report": "reports/experiment-findings.md", "scope": "Executed conditional experiments; no integrated viable field-to-stellar-material history or observed changing constants." }, "spin_isospin_evidence": { "run_ids": [ "20260929T190455973449Z-E24-channels", "20260929T181650699701Z-E25-poles", "20260929T181542357950Z-E26-thresholds", "20260929T184356421226Z-E27-matching", "20260929T184433807545Z-E28-fewbody", "20260929T183855304336Z-E29-rates", "20260929T190007118327Z-E30-BBN", "20260929T182846036271Z-E32-transition", "20260929T182846975883Z-E33-identifiability", "20260929T183418405242Z-E34-isomer", "20260929T190007081746Z-E35-collective" ], "report": "reports/spin-isospin-findings.md", "full_protocol_complete": false, "scope": "Channel-resolved components and conditional histories; no viable integrated threshold-crossing field model or observation." }, "public_input_evidence": { "run_ids": [ "20261005T054523775716Z-W13-quarkmass-sensitivities-method", "20261005T014721094724Z-W02-quartet-full-phase-synthesis", "20261004T041239868634Z-W02-quartet-bin-synthesis", "20261003T223509360913Z-W05-fourbody-projection-benchmark", "20261003T222353411802Z-W08-helium-collision-precision-production", "20261003T210732675805Z-W04-charged-odd-audit", "20261003T204902133504Z-W13-quarkmass-bracketed-survey", "20261003T192457580506Z-W05-STM-attached-contact", "20261003T192357984026Z-W13-quarkmass-matching", "20261003T182902516499Z-W05-STM-contact-derivation", "20261003T002752613991Z-W08-hydrogenic-two-photon-production", "20261002T173014347683Z-W06-np-M1-production", "20261002T173536290414Z-W08-hydrogenic-cascade-production", "20261003T012657182307Z-E28-STM-fourbody-operator", "20261002T233210243361Z-E29-matched-transfer-subset", "20261002T180944135969Z-E28-charged-asymptotic-quartet", "20261002T181401505440Z-E28-charged-asymptotic-doublet", "20261002T161505505732Z-E28-fourbody-triplet", "20261002T160255747887Z-E28-doublet-higher-synthesis", "20261002T051954553720Z-E28-fourbody-scattering", "20261002T033607509184Z-E29-ordinary-weak-capture", "20261002T034622487037Z-E28-charged-threebody", "20261002T030901547406Z-E28-charged-cut", "20261002T031242741570Z-E35-projected-canonical-comparison", "20261002T004220697119Z-E28-doublet-exclusive", "20261002T005429768233Z-E35-paired-minima", "20261001T201455286282Z-E29-nn-magnetic-capture", "20261001T195822977198Z-E28-pd-quartet", "20261001T200953928144Z-E35-canonical-correlations", "20261001T200517723231Z-E29-atomic-populations", "20261001T195600924014Z-E29-atomic-inclusive", "20261001T200436164207Z-E35-cold-pairing", "20261001T193750915211Z-E24-basis-audit", "20261001T194240334391Z-E29-network-contract", "20261001T193548336872Z-E28-exclusive-partial", "20260929T214425497398Z-E24-posterior", "20260929T203530228825Z-E25-Bonn", "20260929T193546300964Z-E26-thermal", "20260929T193546599340Z-E28-scattering", "20260929T201030373477Z-E29-current", "20260929T194839837161Z-E29-source-rates", "20260929T201313664523Z-E29-transfer", "20260929T201633081739Z-E30-source-BBN", "20260929T201029195741Z-E30-compensation", "20260929T203401050040Z-E30-likelihood", "20260929T213258904696Z-E30-STM-BBN", "20260929T223004324566Z-E28-response-consistency", "20260929T224825117361Z-E28-charged", "20260929T225832801441Z-E28-pd-scattering", "20260929T231113457755Z-E28-fourbody", "20260929T232225018002Z-E28-fourbody-refinement", "20260929T233754706450Z-E28-spin-complete", "20260930T004330382653Z-E28-spin-validation", "20260930T005420065273Z-E28-threshold-refinement", "20260930T005525250915Z-E29-trinucleon-weak", "20260930T040332257433Z-E29-trinucleon-thermal", "20260930T005709594476Z-E29-axial-contact", "20260929T214035686025Z-E30-PRIMAT", "20260929T201314827757Z-E35-virial", "20260929T234708649318Z-E35-tightbinding", "20260930T001827978384Z-E35-lattice-manybody", "20260930T022824997049Z-E35-NO2B-audit", "20260930T010050322377Z-E35-lattice-HF", "20260930T011129639631Z-E35-HF-stability", "20260930T015504482144Z-E35-lattice-matching", "20260930T015717334889Z-E35-HF-species", "20260930T020233243143Z-E35-HF-unrestricted", "20260930T020842489784Z-E35-HF-paths", "20260930T030807570905Z-E35-finite-CCSD", "20260930T164749835215Z-E35-finite-clusters", "20260930T183857233297Z-E35-finite-exact", "20260930T195637530757Z-E28-neutral-breakup", "20260930T200800704743Z-E29-atomic-capture", "20260930T194538217202Z-E35-thermal-ensembles", "20260930T194712301119Z-E35-canonical-alpha", "20260930T205654839089Z-E28-pd-partial-waves", "20260930T210235602482Z-E35-thermal-density", "20260930T210506521193Z-E29-atomic-mass", "20260930T213850623642Z-E28-exclusive-breakup", "20260930T213334223420Z-E35-thermal-pairing", "20261005T103445506986Z-W08-helium-boundfree-channels-method", "20261005T110634262292Z-W09-pending27-independent-synthesis", "20261008T083447928357Z-W04-screened-continuation-C2" ], "report": "reports/public-input-findings.md", "scope": "Public-source calculations and explicitly conditional models; no integrated viable field history or observed changing-constants signal." } }, { "id": "C03", "statement": "The field-induced nuclear changes leave appreciable, distinguishable stellar-yield differences after physical compensation.", "status": "stellar_core_response_demonstrated_distinct_ejecta_unresolved", "scope": "Actual stars adjust their structure yet retain substantial core carbon/oxygen differences under imposed rate changes. Winds and terminal ejecta must be distinguished; a uniquely field-induced population yield is not established.", "evidence": [ "runs/20260927T065733690412Z-E03-extended/manifest.json", "runs/20260927T162453968489Z-E04-summary/manifest.json", "runs/20260927T162544293587Z-E11-enrichment/manifest.json", "runs/20260927T163106020428Z-E14-integrated/manifest.json" ], "sources": [ "S01", "S02", "S03", "S08", "S11", "S12", "S13" ], "experiments": [ "E01", "E02", "E03", "E04", "E14" ], "strengthen": "One matched field point produces robust changes in ejected yields or release times beyond ordinary stellar and nuclear nuisance ranges.", "weaken": "Stellar adjustment, correlated rates or alternative pathways erase the effect or make it indistinguishable from ordinary variation.", "new_run_ids": [ "20260927T065733690412Z-E03-extended", "20260927T162453968489Z-E04-summary", "20260927T162544293587Z-E11-enrichment", "20260927T163106020428Z-E14-integrated" ], "new_computations_in_this_handoff": false, "permitted_article_language": "Actual stars adjust their structure yet retain substantial core carbon/oxygen differences under imposed rate changes. Winds and terminal ejecta must be distinguished; a uniquely field-induced population yield is not established.", "inherited_status": "unresolved_beyond_restricted_network", "new_computations_in_campaign": true, "experiment_evidence": { "run_ids": [ "20260929T024518646066Z-P5-material" ], "report": "reports/experiment-findings.md", "scope": "Executed conditional experiments; no integrated viable field-to-stellar-material history or observed changing constants." }, "spin_isospin_evidence": { "run_ids": [ "20260929T183143666644Z-E31-ignition" ], "report": "reports/spin-isospin-findings.md", "full_protocol_complete": false, "scope": "Channel-resolved components and conditional histories; no viable integrated threshold-crossing field model or observation." }, "public_input_evidence": { "run_ids": [ "20261003T000352021101Z-E31-stellar-microphysics-interface", "20261002T152911955527Z-W19-material-transport-production", "20260929T193751335229Z-E31-contraction" ], "report": "reports/public-input-findings.md", "scope": "Public-source calculations and explicitly conditional models; no integrated viable field history or observed changing-constants signal." } }, { "id": "C04", "statement": "A phase excludes organized chemistry or life in general.", "status": "universal_exclusion_not_established_adaptation_counterexample", "scope": "Molecular rescaling and a defined adaptable maintenance network supply counterexamples to universal chemical failure. No calculation here excludes all organized chemistry or life.", "evidence": [ "runs/20260927T061356137462Z-E09-extended/manifest.json", "runs/20260927T141724466374Z-E09-function/manifest.json" ], "sources": [], "experiments": [ "E09", "E14" ], "strengthen": "Demonstrate loss of an explicit function across a defined adaptable class of systems and environments; retain that restricted scope.", "weaken": "An allowed compensatory implementation preserves the tested function. No universal conclusion follows from untested alternatives.", "new_run_ids": [ "20260927T061356137462Z-E09-extended", "20260927T141724466374Z-E09-function" ], "new_computations_in_this_handoff": false, "permitted_article_language": "Molecular rescaling and a defined adaptable maintenance network supply counterexamples to universal chemical failure. No calculation here excludes all organized chemistry or life.", "inherited_status": "not_established_and_not_a_default_endpoint", "new_computations_in_campaign": true, "public_input_evidence": { "run_ids": [ "20261004T032304378062Z-P4-axion-pion-NLO", "20261003T204902133504Z-W13-quarkmass-bracketed-survey", "20261003T192357984026Z-W13-quarkmass-matching", "20261002T030017444607Z-P4-discrete-axion" ], "report": "reports/public-input-findings.md", "scope": "Public-source calculations and explicitly conditional models; no integrated viable field history or observed changing-constants signal." } }, { "id": "C05", "statement": "The proposed phases have a relevant population, lifetime and transition rate.", "status": "actions_and_dynamics_computed_population_unresolved", "scope": "Quantum and thermal actions and real-time boundaries are computed in declared models. Prefactor and formation-history gaps prevent a predicted cosmic phase population or lifetime.", "evidence": [ "runs/20260927T140828510865Z-E06-coupled-modes/manifest.json", "runs/20260927T065507570314Z-E06-dynamics/manifest.json", "runs/20260927T124610990053Z-E06-bubbles/manifest.json", "runs/20260927T071144922221Z-E08-histories/manifest.json" ], "sources": [ "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21" ], "experiments": [ "E00", "E06", "E08" ], "strengthen": "Find populated phases and converged transition probabilities in a controlled effective theory and cosmological history.", "weaken": "Desired phases are never populated, decay too early, never transition when the mechanism requires it, or require an invalid approximation.", "new_run_ids": [ "20260927T140828510865Z-E06-coupled-modes", "20260927T065507570314Z-E06-dynamics", "20260927T124610990053Z-E06-bubbles", "20260927T071144922221Z-E08-histories" ], "new_computations_in_this_handoff": false, "permitted_article_language": "Quantum and thermal actions and real-time boundaries are computed in declared models. Prefactor and formation-history gaps prevent a predicted cosmic phase population or lifetime.", "inherited_status": "illustrative_inherited_bounce_not_a_cosmic_lifetime_measurement", "new_computations_in_campaign": true, "experiment_evidence": { "run_ids": [ "20260929T031718343243Z-P4-dynamics", "20260929T024540159269Z-P4-region-audit" ], "report": "reports/experiment-findings.md", "scope": "Executed conditional experiments; no integrated viable field-to-stellar-material history or observed changing constants." }, "spin_isospin_evidence": { "run_ids": [ "20260929T182846036271Z-E32-transition" ], "report": "reports/spin-isospin-findings.md", "full_protocol_complete": false, "scope": "Channel-resolved components and conditional histories; no viable integrated threshold-crossing field model or observation." }, "public_input_evidence": { "run_ids": [ "20261004T021005808326Z-W28-fermi-fission-production", "20261003T005017200095Z-E21-domain-walls-production", "20261002T154910351865Z-E17-fermi-angular", "20261002T051103348444Z-E21-isotropic-domains", "20261002T143916605596Z-E17-fermi-profile-synthesis", "20261008T082632719274Z-W29-six-case-tau120-production" ], "report": "reports/public-input-findings.md", "scope": "Public-source calculations and explicitly conditional models; no integrated viable field history or observed changing-constants signal." } }, { "id": "C06", "statement": "Distinct phases can form otherwise ordinary regions with different chemistry.", "status": "simple_persistent_region_interpretation_not_established", "scope": "Gravitational bounce controls and scale variants do not produce a benign populated region with the assumed ordinary stars. This is a limitation of the tested constructions, not a universal no-go theorem.", "evidence": [ "runs/20260927T064011591343Z-E05-E06-fields/manifest.json", "runs/20260927T123831205387Z-E12-constraints/manifest.json", "runs/20260927T163106020428Z-E14-integrated/manifest.json" ], "sources": [ "S14", "S18", "S21", "S30" ], "experiments": [ "E05", "E06", "E07", "E14" ], "strengthen": "Demonstrate acceptable field, wall and gravitational evolution at the relevant epoch and scale while retaining the required matter differences.", "weaken": "The specific region cannot maintain the ordinary matter structures assumed by the hypothesis; distinguish terminal transitions from gentle changes.", "new_run_ids": [ "20260927T064011591343Z-E05-E06-fields", "20260927T123831205387Z-E12-constraints", "20260927T163106020428Z-E14-integrated" ], "new_computations_in_this_handoff": false, "permitted_article_language": "Gravitational bounce controls and scale variants do not produce a benign populated region with the assumed ordinary stars. This is a limitation of the tested constructions, not a universal no-go theorem.", "inherited_status": "obstructed_in_legacy_benchmark_not_generally_excluded", "new_computations_in_campaign": true, "next_phase_evidence": { "run_ids": [ "20260929T001332630558Z-E15-viability" ], "report": "reports/next-phase-findings.md", "scope": "Additional diagnostics and gates; no upgrade to an observed or integrated claim." }, "buildout_evidence": { "run_ids": [ "20260929T004604418212Z-P4-matter" ], "report": "reports/buildout-findings.md", "scope": "Scoped controls/non-identifiability, not a detected or viable integrated model." }, "experiment_evidence": { "run_ids": [ "20260929T023344889478Z-P4-interacting", "20260929T024540159269Z-P4-region-audit", "20260929T031718343243Z-P4-dynamics" ], "report": "reports/experiment-findings.md", "scope": "Executed conditional experiments; no integrated viable field-to-stellar-material history or observed changing constants." }, "spin_isospin_evidence": { "run_ids": [ "20260929T184356421226Z-E27-matching", "20260929T190007081746Z-E35-collective" ], "report": "reports/spin-isospin-findings.md", "full_protocol_complete": false, "scope": "Channel-resolved components and conditional histories; no viable integrated threshold-crossing field model or observation." }, "public_input_evidence": { "run_ids": [ "20261005T033150137042Z-W27-triaxial-production-combine", "20261004T032304378062Z-P4-axion-pion-NLO", "20261004T025604096938Z-W10-Gaussian-phase-polished-continuation-production", "20261003T184423636738Z-W03-paired-curvature-budget-production", "20261003T062634112832Z-W03-paired-volume-continuation-A1", "20261003T062901596918Z-W03-paired-volume-continuation-B2", "20261003T023731930584Z-W27-axisymmetric-production", "20261003T004614613211Z-W03-cold-charge-increment-production", "20261002T235807925724Z-W03-paired-charge-response-B", "20261002T163445174412Z-W03-paired-volume-L3", "20261002T151355513739Z-E06-scalar-hydrodynamics", "20261002T033859036026Z-W27-W30-nonspherical", "20261002T031242741570Z-E35-projected-canonical-comparison", "20261002T030017444607Z-P4-discrete-axion", "20261002T005429768233Z-E35-paired-minima", "20261001T200436164207Z-E35-cold-pairing", "20261001T200953928144Z-E35-canonical-correlations", "20260929T220308671706Z-E32-coupled", "20260929T200930246324Z-E34-measured", "20260930T181150182339Z-E34-environment", "20260929T201314827757Z-E35-virial", "20260929T234708649318Z-E35-tightbinding", "20260930T001827978384Z-E35-lattice-manybody", "20260930T022824997049Z-E35-NO2B-audit", "20260930T010050322377Z-E35-lattice-HF", "20260930T011129639631Z-E35-HF-stability", "20260930T015504482144Z-E35-lattice-matching", "20260930T015717334889Z-E35-HF-species", "20260930T020233243143Z-E35-HF-unrestricted", "20260930T020842489784Z-E35-HF-paths", "20260930T030807570905Z-E35-finite-CCSD", "20260930T164749835215Z-E35-finite-clusters", "20260930T183857233297Z-E35-finite-exact", "20260930T194538217202Z-E35-thermal-ensembles", "20260930T194712301119Z-E35-canonical-alpha", "20260930T210235602482Z-E35-thermal-density", "20260930T213334223420Z-E35-thermal-pairing", "20261005T110634262292Z-W09-pending27-independent-synthesis", "20261008T084340391725Z-W10-Gaussian-upper-neutral-block-cost" ], "report": "reports/public-input-findings.md", "scope": "Public-source calculations and explicitly conditional models; no integrated viable field history or observed changing-constants signal." } }, { "id": "C07", "statement": "The same parameter point is consistent with the observations appropriate to its place, epoch and environment.", "status": "component_constraints_no_joint_allowed_history", "scope": "Applicable local summaries and synthetic recoveries are evaluated. No single complete field history passes all needed matter, population and observational checks.", "evidence": [ "runs/20260927T123223276223Z-E10-conditional/manifest.json", "runs/20260927T123831205387Z-E12-constraints/manifest.json", "runs/20260927T121631158013Z-E12-BBN-matched/manifest.json", "runs/20260927T163106020428Z-E14-integrated/manifest.json" ], "sources": [ "S15", "S23", "S24", "S25", "S27", "S28", "S29" ], "experiments": [ "E05", "E07", "E10", "E12", "E14" ], "strengthen": "Jointly predict the relevant observables with nuisance modeling and successful injection recovery, using the same theory point.", "weaken": "A correctly mapped measurement excludes that point, or a claimed signal is reproduced by calibrated systematic effects.", "new_run_ids": [ "20260927T123223276223Z-E10-conditional", "20260927T123831205387Z-E12-constraints", "20260927T121631158013Z-E12-BBN-matched", "20260927T163106020428Z-E14-integrated" ], "new_computations_in_this_handoff": false, "permitted_article_language": "Applicable local summaries and synthetic recoveries are evaluated. No single complete field history passes all needed matter, population and observational checks.", "inherited_status": "no_integrated_fit_yet", "new_computations_in_campaign": true, "next_phase_evidence": { "run_ids": [ "20260929T000850263108Z-E20-information", "20260929T001332630558Z-E15-viability" ], "report": "reports/next-phase-findings.md", "scope": "Additional diagnostics and gates; no upgrade to an observed or integrated claim." }, "buildout_evidence": { "run_ids": [ "20260929T004604431906Z-E20-profile" ], "report": "reports/buildout-findings.md", "scope": "Scoped controls/non-identifiability, not a detected or viable integrated model." }, "experiment_evidence": { "run_ids": [ "20260929T030548291050Z-E20-joint" ], "report": "reports/experiment-findings.md", "scope": "Executed conditional experiments; no integrated viable field-to-stellar-material history or observed changing constants." }, "public_input_evidence": { "run_ids": [ "20261004T035729512575Z-E10-spectral-dense-continuation-production", "20261003T020128144049Z-W23-GNSS-fresh-production", "20261003T014345831882Z-W23-GNSS-temporal", "20261002T062354709266Z-W23-GNSS-clocks" ], "report": "reports/public-input-findings.md", "scope": "Public-source calculations and explicitly conditional models; no integrated viable field history or observed changing-constants signal." } }, { "id": "C08", "statement": "Global rarity and transition latency reduce suitable opportunities near an observer like us.", "status": "conditioning_and_causality_counterexamples_validated", "scope": "Global phase rarity alone does not determine opportunities near a surviving observer. Shared histories, duration conditioning and past-light-cone selection change the relevant statistics.", "evidence": [ "runs/20260927T071144922221Z-E08-histories/manifest.json", "runs/20260927T122957970444Z-E08-domains/manifest.json", "runs/20260927T130103425275Z-E08-field-fronts/manifest.json" ], "sources": [], "experiments": [ "E08", "E14" ], "strengthen": "A dynamically specified history reduces relevant nearby intervals after observer conditioning and past-light-cone selection.", "weaken": "Conditioning restores broad local opportunity or surviving observers cannot receive the proposed post-transition evidence.", "new_run_ids": [ "20260927T071144922221Z-E08-histories", "20260927T122957970444Z-E08-domains", "20260927T130103425275Z-E08-field-fronts" ], "new_computations_in_this_handoff": false, "permitted_article_language": "Global phase rarity alone does not determine opportunities near a surviving observer. Shared histories, duration conditioning and past-light-cone selection change the relevant statistics.", "inherited_status": "not_automatic_counterexample_in_fast_front_toy_history", "new_computations_in_campaign": true, "public_input_evidence": { "run_ids": [ "20261003T005017200095Z-E21-domain-walls-production", "20261002T150703457054Z-E08-history-contract", "20261002T051103348444Z-E21-isotropic-domains", "20261008T082632719274Z-W29-six-case-tau120-production" ], "report": "reports/public-input-findings.md", "scope": "Public-source calculations and explicitly conditional models; no integrated viable field history or observed changing-constants signal." } }, { "id": "C09", "statement": "Environmental field dependence preserves matter differences in the environments that matter while satisfying screening constraints.", "status": "tested_screening_erases_core_nuclear_difference", "scope": "The tested screened stellar burning region agrees with dense Earth in alpha, erasing that nuclear contrast. The photon benchmark also violates its fixed-planet force assumption.", "evidence": [ "runs/20260927T134204118612Z-E07-stellar/manifest.json", "runs/20260927T141929700876Z-E07-matter/manifest.json", "runs/20260927T123831205387Z-E12-constraints/manifest.json" ], "sources": [ "S15", "S22", "S27" ], "experiments": [ "E05", "E06", "E07", "E12" ], "strengthen": "Solve distinct, stable field profiles inside relevant stars or chemical systems with appropriate exterior profiles and force limits.", "weaken": "Screening erases the desired interior differences, phases are observationally equivalent, or the required transition is absent.", "new_run_ids": [ "20260927T134204118612Z-E07-stellar", "20260927T141929700876Z-E07-matter", "20260927T123831205387Z-E12-constraints" ], "new_computations_in_this_handoff": false, "permitted_article_language": "The tested screened stellar burning region agrees with dense Earth in alpha, erasing that nuclear contrast. The photon benchmark also violates its fixed-planet force assumption.", "inherited_status": "proposed_model_family_M2", "new_computations_in_campaign": true }, { "id": "C10", "statement": "A temporary field phase can leave a distinguishable enrichment signature after local particle properties converge.", "status": "prescribed_temporary_wind_record_computed_identifiability_tested", "scope": "A prescribed temporary rate history can leave a delayed wind-enrichment record after rates return. Formation, terminal ejecta and distinction from ordinary enrichment remain separate requirements.", "evidence": [ "runs/20260927T145256317601Z-E04-transitions/manifest.json", "runs/20260927T162544293587Z-E11-enrichment/manifest.json", "runs/20260927T163106020428Z-E14-integrated/manifest.json" ], "sources": [ "S11", "S12", "S26", "S29" ], "experiments": [ "E04", "E06", "E08", "E11", "E14" ], "strengthen": "A persistent multi-element or isotope signature survives mixing and ordinary enrichment alternatives and matches independent tests.", "weaken": "Mixing erases it, alternative stellar histories explain it, or observations exclude the phase during its active epoch.", "new_run_ids": [ "20260927T145256317601Z-E04-transitions", "20260927T162544293587Z-E11-enrichment", "20260927T163106020428Z-E14-integrated" ], "new_computations_in_this_handoff": false, "permitted_article_language": "A prescribed temporary rate history can leave a delayed wind-enrichment record after rates return. Formation, terminal ejecta and distinction from ordinary enrichment remain separate requirements.", "inherited_status": "proposed_model_family_M3", "new_computations_in_campaign": true, "experiment_evidence": { "run_ids": [ "20260929T024518646066Z-P5-material", "20260929T025855993746Z-P5-clouds" ], "report": "reports/experiment-findings.md", "scope": "Executed conditional experiments; no integrated viable field-to-stellar-material history or observed changing constants." }, "spin_isospin_evidence": { "run_ids": [ "20260929T190007118327Z-E30-BBN", "20260929T183143666644Z-E31-ignition" ], "report": "reports/spin-isospin-findings.md", "full_protocol_complete": false, "scope": "Channel-resolved components and conditional histories; no viable integrated threshold-crossing field model or observation." }, "public_input_evidence": { "run_ids": [ "20261005T033150137042Z-W27-triaxial-production-combine", "20261005T014721094724Z-W02-quartet-full-phase-synthesis", "20261004T041239868634Z-W02-quartet-bin-synthesis", "20261004T025604096938Z-W10-Gaussian-phase-polished-continuation-production", "20261003T223509360913Z-W05-fourbody-projection-benchmark", "20261003T222353411802Z-W08-helium-collision-precision-production", "20261003T210732675805Z-W04-charged-odd-audit", "20261003T204902133504Z-W13-quarkmass-bracketed-survey", "20261003T192457580506Z-W05-STM-attached-contact", "20261003T192357984026Z-W13-quarkmass-matching", "20261003T182902516499Z-W05-STM-contact-derivation", "20261003T070802616726Z-W02-coherent-breakup-synthesis", "20261003T064522393857Z-W07-atomic-VP-production", "20261003T020428615811Z-W20-molecular-kinetics-production", "20261003T002752613991Z-W08-hydrogenic-two-photon-production", "20261003T000352021101Z-E31-stellar-microphysics-interface", "20261002T233210243361Z-E29-matched-transfer-subset", "20261002T180944135969Z-E28-charged-asymptotic-quartet", "20261002T181401505440Z-E28-charged-asymptotic-doublet", "20261002T173014347683Z-W06-np-M1-production", "20261002T173536290414Z-W08-hydrogenic-cascade-production", "20261002T161505505732Z-E28-fourbody-triplet", "20261002T151355513739Z-E06-scalar-hydrodynamics", "20261002T152911955527Z-W19-material-transport-production", "20261002T160255747887Z-E28-doublet-higher-synthesis", "20261002T144143151210Z-W08-hydrogenic-production", "20261002T051954553720Z-E28-fourbody-scattering", "20261002T061100483981Z-W20-molecular-cooling", "20261002T033607509184Z-E29-ordinary-weak-capture", "20261002T034622487037Z-E28-charged-threebody", "20261002T030901547406Z-E28-charged-cut", "20261002T004220697119Z-E28-doublet-exclusive", "20261001T201455286282Z-E29-nn-magnetic-capture", "20261001T195822977198Z-E28-pd-quartet", "20261001T195600924014Z-E29-atomic-inclusive", "20261001T200517723231Z-E29-atomic-populations", "20261001T194240334391Z-E29-network-contract", "20261001T193548336872Z-E28-exclusive-partial", "20260929T201633081739Z-E30-source-BBN", "20260929T203401050040Z-E30-likelihood", "20260929T213258904696Z-E30-STM-BBN", "20260929T223004324566Z-E28-response-consistency", "20260929T224825117361Z-E28-charged", "20260929T233754706450Z-E28-spin-complete", "20260930T005420065273Z-E28-threshold-refinement", "20260930T005525250915Z-E29-trinucleon-weak", "20260930T040332257433Z-E29-trinucleon-thermal", "20260930T005709594476Z-E29-axial-contact", "20260930T200800704743Z-E29-atomic-capture", "20260930T210506521193Z-E29-atomic-mass", "20260930T195637530757Z-E28-neutral-breakup", "20260930T205654839089Z-E28-pd-partial-waves", "20260930T213850623642Z-E28-exclusive-breakup", "20260929T193751335229Z-E31-contraction", "20261005T103445506986Z-W08-helium-boundfree-channels-method", "20261005T074140278056Z-W20-molecular-forcing-tube-method" ], "report": "reports/public-input-findings.md", "scope": "Public-source calculations and explicitly conditional models; no integrated viable field history or observed changing-constants signal." } }, { "id": "C11", "statement": "A passing boundary can disrupt an organized system even if both endpoint chemistries are viable.", "status": "molecular_excitation_and_work_computed_system_disruption_unresolved", "scope": "A time-dependent molecular Hamiltonian produces duration-dependent excitation with accounted background work. A closed fixed-nuclei H2 basis does not establish dissociation or disruption of an organism.", "evidence": [ "runs/20260927T065507570314Z-E06-dynamics/manifest.json", "runs/20260927T061356137462Z-E09-extended/manifest.json", "runs/20260927T134046614274Z-E09-traces/manifest.json" ], "sources": [ "S20", "S33" ], "experiments": [ "E06", "E07", "E09" ], "strengthen": "Use a matched transition timescale to demonstrate reproducible function loss beyond recoverable excitation and allowed adaptation.", "weaken": "Adiabatic adjustment or relaxation preserves function, or all effects are explained by excluded energy injection.", "new_run_ids": [ "20260927T065507570314Z-E06-dynamics", "20260927T061356137462Z-E09-extended", "20260927T134046614274Z-E09-traces" ], "new_computations_in_this_handoff": false, "permitted_article_language": "A time-dependent molecular Hamiltonian produces duration-dependent excitation with accounted background work. A closed fixed-nuclei H2 basis does not establish dissociation or disruption of an organism.", "inherited_status": "proposed_dynamical_chemistry_experiment", "new_computations_in_campaign": true }, { "id": "C12", "statement": "A unified model explains the absence of detectable peers.", "status": "no_unified_explanation_established", "scope": "No tested implementation establishes an explanation of the absence of detectable peers.", "evidence": [ "runs/20260927T163106020428Z-E14-integrated/manifest.json" ], "sources": [ "S35" ], "experiments": [ "E03", "E04", "E05", "E06", "E07", "E08", "E09", "E10", "E11", "E12", "E14" ], "strengthen": "One viable physical history changes the observer-conditioned detection prediction compared with documented ordinary alternatives, with emergence and detection uncertainties explicit.", "weaken": "Component effects cannot coexist, conditioning removes the effect, or detection predictions are dominated by unconstrained added assumptions.", "new_run_ids": [ "20260927T163106020428Z-E14-integrated" ], "new_computations_in_this_handoff": false, "permitted_article_language": "No tested implementation establishes an explanation of the absence of detectable peers.", "inherited_status": "not_established", "new_computations_in_campaign": true, "public_input_evidence": { "run_ids": [ "20261002T150703457054Z-E08-history-contract" ], "report": "reports/public-input-findings.md", "scope": "Public-source calculations and explicitly conditional models; no integrated viable field history or observed changing-constants signal." } }, { "id": "C13", "statement": "Leading nonrelativistic Coulomb rescaling preserves the dimensionless electronic landscape under its assumptions.", "status": "atomic_and_molecular_scaling_validated", "scope": "Hydrogen, H2 and water recover leading Coulomb dilation in the appropriate units. Nuclear masses, relativity, nonadiabatic driving and environmental conditions are distinct corrections.", "evidence": [ "runs/20260927T061356137462Z-E09-extended/manifest.json", "runs/20260927T141724466374Z-E09-function/manifest.json" ], "sources": [ "S32", "S33" ], "experiments": [ "E09" ], "strengthen": "Reproduce atomic/molecular rescaling after units are transformed; isolate residual relativistic, nuclear-motion and environmental effects.", "weaken": "A claimed violation within the stated exact scaling assumptions signals an implementation error; outside them it is a new calculation, not a contradiction.", "new_run_ids": [ "20260927T061356137462Z-E09-extended", "20260927T141724466374Z-E09-function" ], "new_computations_in_this_handoff": false, "permitted_article_language": "Hydrogen, H2 and water recover leading Coulomb dilation in the appropriate units. Nuclear masses, relativity, nonadiabatic driving and environmental conditions are distinct corrections.", "inherited_status": "analytic_null_control_with_legacy_numerical_check", "new_computations_in_campaign": true }, { "id": "C14", "statement": "The phase model predicts an observable pattern distinguishable from ordinary nuisance variation.", "status": "observed_distinctive_signature_not_established", "scope": "Calibration and ordinary enrichment can imitate candidate patterns. Conditional real-spectrum fits and internal held-out outputs do not establish a distinctive observed field signature.", "evidence": [ "runs/20260927T070724025464Z-E10-spectra/manifest.json", "runs/20260927T123223276223Z-E10-conditional/manifest.json", "runs/20260927T124027728147Z-E11-abundances/manifest.json", "runs/20260927T163106020428Z-E14-integrated/manifest.json" ], "sources": [ "S23", "S24", "S25", "S26", "S27", "S28" ], "experiments": [ "E04", "E10", "E11", "E12", "E14" ], "strengthen": "A frozen prediction survives held-out tests and realistic nuisance variation; any real-data evidence is reported with the comparison model and limits.", "weaken": "The effect lies in an ordinary nuisance direction, fails injection recovery or is unsupported outside training/calibration data.", "new_run_ids": [ "20260927T070724025464Z-E10-spectra", "20260927T123223276223Z-E10-conditional", "20260927T124027728147Z-E11-abundances", "20260927T163106020428Z-E14-integrated" ], "new_computations_in_this_handoff": false, "permitted_article_language": "Calibration and ordinary enrichment can imitate candidate patterns. Conditional real-spectrum fits and internal held-out outputs do not establish a distinctive observed field signature.", "inherited_status": "unresolved_no_new_observational_fit", "new_computations_in_campaign": true, "next_phase_evidence": { "run_ids": [ "20260929T000850263108Z-E20-information" ], "report": "reports/next-phase-findings.md", "scope": "Additional diagnostics and gates; no upgrade to an observed or integrated claim." }, "buildout_evidence": { "run_ids": [ "20260929T004604431906Z-E20-profile" ], "report": "reports/buildout-findings.md", "scope": "Scoped controls/non-identifiability, not a detected or viable integrated model." }, "experiment_evidence": { "run_ids": [ "20260929T030548291050Z-E20-joint", "20260929T024518646066Z-P5-material", "20260929T025855993746Z-P5-clouds" ], "report": "reports/experiment-findings.md", "scope": "Executed conditional experiments; no integrated viable field-to-stellar-material history or observed changing constants." }, "spin_isospin_evidence": { "run_ids": [ "20260929T182846975883Z-E33-identifiability" ], "report": "reports/spin-isospin-findings.md", "full_protocol_complete": false, "scope": "Channel-resolved components and conditional histories; no viable integrated threshold-crossing field model or observation." }, "public_input_evidence": { "run_ids": [ "20261004T035729512575Z-E10-spectral-dense-continuation-production", "20261003T020128144049Z-W23-GNSS-fresh-production", "20261003T014345831882Z-W23-GNSS-temporal", "20261002T150051218776Z-W21-isotope-exchange", "20261002T062354709266Z-W23-GNSS-clocks", "20261002T062007216298Z-E23-snapshot-likelihood", "20261001T193750915211Z-E24-basis-audit", "20260929T214425497398Z-E24-posterior", "20260929T203401050040Z-E30-likelihood", "20260929T200528580709Z-E33-data", "20261008T075722716663Z-W21-nonidentifiability" ], "report": "reports/public-input-findings.md", "scope": "Public-source calculations and explicitly conditional models; no integrated viable field history or observed changing-constants signal." } }, { "id": "C15", "statement": "A localized or oscillatory field configuration can provide the alternative persistence mechanism.", "status": "canonical_oscillon_component_tested_no_complete_persistence_model", "scope": "Specified canonical oscillons persist or radiate within finite numerical windows. Dimensional times, nonspherical stability, formation and a physically valid matched matter response prevent a complete alternative persistence claim.", "evidence": [ "runs/20260927T114301879794Z-E13-oscillons/manifest.json", "runs/20260927T123100002963Z-E13-chemistry/manifest.json", "runs/20260927T163106020428Z-E14-integrated/manifest.json" ], "sources": [ "S34" ], "experiments": [ "E13", "E05", "E09", "E12", "E14" ], "strengthen": "Reproduce a specified configuration with converged radiation losses, lifetime, matter coupling and environmental constraints.", "weaken": "Boundary reflections create the apparent persistence, decay is too rapid, or the chosen kinetic theory is unstable or outside its validity domain.", "new_run_ids": [ "20260927T114301879794Z-E13-oscillons", "20260927T123100002963Z-E13-chemistry", "20260927T163106020428Z-E14-integrated" ], "new_computations_in_this_handoff": false, "permitted_article_language": "Specified canonical oscillons persist or radiate within finite numerical windows. Dimensional times, nonspherical stability, formation and a physically valid matched matter response prevent a complete alternative persistence claim.", "inherited_status": "optional_model_family_M4_not_implemented", "new_computations_in_campaign": true, "public_input_evidence": { "run_ids": [ "20261002T154910351865Z-E17-fermi-angular", "20261002T062007216298Z-E23-snapshot-likelihood", "20261002T143916605596Z-E17-fermi-profile-synthesis" ], "report": "reports/public-input-findings.md", "scope": "Public-source calculations and explicitly conditional models; no integrated viable field history or observed changing-constants signal." } } ], "revision_utc": "2026-10-05T12:56:21.854398+00:00" }