{ "schema_version": 1, "prepared_on": "2026-09-24", "note": "Component pilot. Run validation describes numerical scope, not truth of the complete claim. Original ledger is preserved under data/raw/handoff.", "claims": [ { "id": "C01", "statement": "A specified theory can contain persistent field configurations with distinct effective particle properties.", "status": "classical_benchmark_reproduced", "scope": "The archived scalar\u2013Higgs benchmark. Only its supplied unit tests, not its full two-field calculation, were rerun for this handoff.", "evidence": [ "archive/legacy_report.md", "archive/AUDIT.md" ], "sources": [ "S14", "S17", "S19", "S20" ], "experiments": [ "E00", "E05", "E06" ], "strengthen": "Independently reproduce distinct minima and a valid transition in the same matched effective theory; verify that observable dimensionless couplings differ.", "weaken": "Minima fail stability checks, are physically equivalent, or disappear within relevant corrections; report exclusion only for that model.", "new_run_ids": [ "20260927T015443056558Z-E00", "20260927T015335289373Z-E05" ], "new_computations_in_this_handoff": false, "permitted_article_language": "Two classical stable backgrounds and the inherited bounce reproduce. Corrected theory and observations remain untested.", "inherited_status": "constructed_in_inherited_classical_toy_model", "pilot_scope_note": "Run links concern component checks only; the claim may remain unresolved." }, { "id": "C02", "statement": "Changes in fundamental parameters can change the Hoyle threshold and helium-burning reaction rates.", "status": "local_response_control_validated", "scope": "Local nuclear derivatives under explicitly stated fixed reference scales, input scenarios and validity domains; not an observation of another phase.", "evidence": [], "sources": [ "S01", "S02", "S03", "S04", "S05", "S06" ], "experiments": [ "E01", "E02", "E05" ], "strengthen": "Reproduce evaluated baseline nuclear data and the published responses; calculate complete thermal rates with consistent energy levels and covariance where available.", "weaken": "Correlated threshold changes suppress the claimed response, reverse its sign, or make its magnitude indeterminate under allowed nuclear uncertainties.", "new_run_ids": [ "20260927T015330656008Z-E01", "20260927T015335289373Z-E05" ], "new_computations_in_this_handoff": false, "permitted_article_language": "Fixed-temperature rate response checked; full capture and matched nuclear thresholds remain incomplete.", "inherited_status": "published_model_dependent_response_available", "pilot_scope_note": "Run links concern component checks only; the claim may remain unresolved." }, { "id": "C03", "statement": "The field-induced nuclear changes leave appreciable, distinguishable stellar-yield differences after physical compensation.", "status": "unresolved_beyond_restricted_network", "scope": "The archive changes selected rates in prescribed parcels; density compensation and uncertain competing reactions prevent a general stellar conclusion.", "evidence": [ "archive/legacy_report.md" ], "sources": [ "S01", "S02", "S03", "S08", "S11", "S12", "S13" ], "experiments": [ "E01", "E02", "E03", "E04", "E14" ], "strengthen": "One matched field point produces robust changes in ejected yields or release times beyond ordinary stellar and nuclear nuisance ranges.", "weaken": "Stellar adjustment, correlated rates or alternative pathways erase the effect or make it indistinguishable from ordinary variation.", "new_run_ids": [ "20260927T015330656008Z-E01", "20260927T023342111171Z-E03", "20260927T015444724011Z-E14" ], "new_computations_in_this_handoff": false, "permitted_article_language": "Independent parcel integration confirms changes and exact density compensation; no distinguishable stellar yield is established.", "inherited_status": "unresolved_beyond_restricted_network", "pilot_scope_note": "Run links concern component checks only; the claim may remain unresolved." }, { "id": "C04", "statement": "A phase excludes organized chemistry or life in general.", "status": "not_established_and_not_a_default_endpoint", "scope": "Element yields and failures of selected molecules do not define a universal biological boundary.", "evidence": [], "sources": [], "experiments": [ "E09", "E14" ], "strengthen": "Demonstrate loss of an explicit function across a defined adaptable class of systems and environments; retain that restricted scope.", "weaken": "An allowed compensatory implementation preserves the tested function. No universal conclusion follows from untested alternatives.", "new_run_ids": [], "new_computations_in_this_handoff": false, "permitted_article_language": "Use only the demonstrated functional class; do not describe a region as universally lifeless.", "inherited_status": "not_established_and_not_a_default_endpoint", "pilot_scope_note": "Run links concern component checks only; the claim may remain unresolved." }, { "id": "C05", "statement": "The proposed phases have a relevant population, lifetime and transition rate.", "status": "classical_bounce_reproduced_cosmic_history_unresolved", "scope": "The archived action uses a selected classical potential and assumed prefactor; thermal history, gravity and population were not completed.", "evidence": [ "archive/legacy_report.md" ], "sources": [ "S17", "S18", "S19", "S20", "S21" ], "experiments": [ "E00", "E06", "E08" ], "strengthen": "Find populated phases and converged transition probabilities in a controlled effective theory and cosmological history.", "weaken": "Desired phases are never populated, decay too early, never transition when the mechanism requires it, or require an invalid approximation.", "new_run_ids": [ "20260927T015443056558Z-E00", "20260927T015443415499Z-E08" ], "new_computations_in_this_handoff": false, "permitted_article_language": "The reproduced bounce and radial modes are not a computed cosmic lifetime or phase population.", "inherited_status": "illustrative_inherited_bounce_not_a_cosmic_lifetime_measurement", "pilot_scope_note": "Run links concern component checks only; the claim may remain unresolved." }, { "id": "C06", "statement": "Distinct phases can form otherwise ordinary regions with different chemistry.", "status": "benchmark_energy_difference_reproduced", "scope": "The benchmark has a large energy difference; the ratio to present dark energy and a limited loop diagnostic are not universal exclusion criteria.", "evidence": [ "archive/legacy_report.md" ], "sources": [ "S14", "S18", "S21", "S30" ], "experiments": [ "E05", "E06", "E07", "E14" ], "strengthen": "Demonstrate acceptable field, wall and gravitational evolution at the relevant epoch and scale while retaining the required matter differences.", "weaken": "The specific region cannot maintain the ordinary matter structures assumed by the hypothesis; distinguish terminal transitions from gentle changes.", "new_run_ids": [ "20260927T015335289373Z-E05", "20260927T015443056558Z-E00", "20260927T015335313304Z-E07", "20260927T015444724011Z-E14" ], "new_computations_in_this_handoff": false, "permitted_article_language": "The chosen model's phase-energy difference is large; gravitational evolution is not solved and no general exclusion follows.", "inherited_status": "obstructed_in_legacy_benchmark_not_generally_excluded", "pilot_scope_note": "Run links concern component checks only; the claim may remain unresolved." }, { "id": "C07", "statement": "The same parameter point is consistent with the observations appropriate to its place, epoch and environment.", "status": "no_integrated_fit_yet", "scope": "Published absorber and laboratory measurements constrain specific systems and coupling directions. Different absorbers are not one joint location.", "evidence": [ "archive/legacy_report.md" ], "sources": [ "S15", "S23", "S24", "S25", "S27", "S28", "S29" ], "experiments": [ "E05", "E07", "E10", "E12", "E14" ], "strengthen": "Jointly predict the relevant observables with nuisance modeling and successful injection recovery, using the same theory point.", "weaken": "A correctly mapped measurement excludes that point, or a claimed signal is reproduced by calibrated systematic effects.", "new_run_ids": [], "new_computations_in_this_handoff": false, "permitted_article_language": "Measurements constrain specified systems and interactions; no unified allowed point has been demonstrated here.", "inherited_status": "no_integrated_fit_yet", "pilot_scope_note": "Run links concern component checks only; the claim may remain unresolved." }, { "id": "C08", "statement": "Global rarity and transition latency reduce suitable opportunities near an observer like us.", "status": "counterexample_independently_validated", "scope": "Homogeneous flat-spacetime Poisson fronts yield strong conditional correlation. Alternative physical histories remain to be evaluated.", "evidence": [ "archive/legacy_report.md" ], "sources": [], "experiments": [ "E08", "E14" ], "strengthen": "A dynamically specified history reduces relevant nearby intervals after observer conditioning and past-light-cone selection.", "weaken": "Conditioning restores broad local opportunity or surviving observers cannot receive the proposed post-transition evidence.", "new_run_ids": [ "20260927T015443415499Z-E08", "20260927T015444724011Z-E14" ], "new_computations_in_this_handoff": false, "permitted_article_language": "Global rarity does not imply local solitude in the tested Poisson-front history; causal visibility further restricts the luminal case.", "inherited_status": "not_automatic_counterexample_in_fast_front_toy_history", "pilot_scope_note": "Run links concern component checks only; the claim may remain unresolved." }, { "id": "C09", "statement": "Environmental field dependence preserves matter differences in the environments that matter while satisfying screening constraints.", "status": "linear_screening_control_only", "scope": "A standard symmetron supplies a precedent, not a completed metastable two-chemistry model. Even-coupled plus/minus phases can be equivalent.", "evidence": [], "sources": [ "S15", "S22", "S27" ], "experiments": [ "E05", "E06", "E07", "E12" ], "strengthen": "Solve distinct, stable field profiles inside relevant stars or chemical systems with appropriate exterior profiles and force limits.", "weaken": "Screening erases the desired interior differences, phases are observationally equivalent, or the required transition is absent.", "new_run_ids": [ "20260927T015335289373Z-E05", "20260927T015443056558Z-E00", "20260927T015335313304Z-E07" ], "new_computations_in_this_handoff": false, "permitted_article_language": "A limiting spherical screening equation suppresses the core field; nonlinear matched stellar and force calculations remain absent.", "inherited_status": "proposed_model_family_M2", "pilot_scope_note": "Run links concern component checks only; the claim may remain unresolved." }, { "id": "C10", "statement": "A temporary field phase can leave a distinguishable enrichment signature after local particle properties converge.", "status": "proposed_model_family_M3", "scope": "Requires stellar release delays, transport, mixing, subsequent nucleosynthesis and constraints during the active phase.", "evidence": [], "sources": [ "S11", "S12", "S26", "S29" ], "experiments": [ "E04", "E06", "E08", "E11", "E14" ], "strengthen": "A persistent multi-element or isotope signature survives mixing and ordinary enrichment alternatives and matches independent tests.", "weaken": "Mixing erases it, alternative stellar histories explain it, or observations exclude the phase during its active epoch.", "new_run_ids": [], "new_computations_in_this_handoff": false, "permitted_article_language": "Fossil enrichment is a proposed route to historical evidence.", "inherited_status": "proposed_model_family_M3", "pilot_scope_note": "Run links concern component checks only; the claim may remain unresolved." }, { "id": "C11", "statement": "A passing boundary can disrupt an organized system even if both endpoint chemistries are viable.", "status": "proposed_dynamical_chemistry_experiment", "scope": "Requires a physical wall profile, nonadiabatic response and energy exchange, not arbitrary imposed damage.", "evidence": [], "sources": [ "S20", "S33" ], "experiments": [ "E06", "E07", "E09" ], "strengthen": "Use a matched transition timescale to demonstrate reproducible function loss beyond recoverable excitation and allowed adaptation.", "weaken": "Adiabatic adjustment or relaxation preserves function, or all effects are explained by excluded energy injection.", "new_run_ids": [], "new_computations_in_this_handoff": false, "permitted_article_language": "Transition damage is a question to calculate, not an assumed outcome.", "inherited_status": "proposed_dynamical_chemistry_experiment", "pilot_scope_note": "Run links concern component checks only; the claim may remain unresolved." }, { "id": "C12", "statement": "A unified model explains the absence of detectable peers.", "status": "not_established", "scope": "Distinct from model existence, element yields, altered chemistry, a global phase fraction or an observed spectral departure.", "evidence": [], "sources": [ "S35" ], "experiments": [ "E03", "E04", "E05", "E06", "E07", "E08", "E09", "E10", "E11", "E12", "E14" ], "strengthen": "One viable physical history changes the observer-conditioned detection prediction compared with documented ordinary alternatives, with emergence and detection uncertainties explicit.", "weaken": "Component effects cannot coexist, conditioning removes the effect, or detection predictions are dominated by unconstrained added assumptions.", "new_run_ids": [], "new_computations_in_this_handoff": false, "permitted_article_language": "The Fermi connection is an additional unresolved claim.", "inherited_status": "not_established", "pilot_scope_note": "Run links concern component checks only; the claim may remain unresolved." }, { "id": "C13", "statement": "Leading nonrelativistic Coulomb rescaling preserves the dimensionless electronic landscape under its assumptions.", "status": "hydrogen_scaling_independently_validated", "scope": "Fixed nuclear charges, nonrelativistic electronic Hamiltonian and stated Born\u2013Oppenheimer assumptions; not arbitrary nuclear masses or relativistic chemistry.", "evidence": [ "archive/legacy_report.md" ], "sources": [ "S32", "S33" ], "experiments": [ "E09" ], "strengthen": "Reproduce atomic/molecular rescaling after units are transformed; isolate residual relativistic, nuclear-motion and environmental effects.", "weaken": "A claimed violation within the stated exact scaling assumptions signals an implementation error; outside them it is a new calculation, not a contradiction.", "new_run_ids": [ "20260927T015444052071Z-E09" ], "new_computations_in_this_handoff": false, "permitted_article_language": "Hydrogen spectra collapse in rescaled units, with mesh convergence; molecular and non-scaling effects remain uncomputed.", "inherited_status": "analytic_null_control_with_legacy_numerical_check", "pilot_scope_note": "Run links concern component checks only; the claim may remain unresolved." }, { "id": "C14", "statement": "The phase model predicts an observable pattern distinguishable from ordinary nuisance variation.", "status": "composition_signal_degenerate_in_restricted_network", "scope": "Synthetic recovery, model-uncertainty propagation and physically matched cross-observable predictions are required.", "evidence": [], "sources": [ "S23", "S24", "S25", "S26", "S27", "S28" ], "experiments": [ "E04", "E10", "E11", "E12", "E14" ], "strengthen": "A frozen prediction survives held-out tests and realistic nuisance variation; any real-data evidence is reported with the comparison model and limits.", "weaken": "The effect lies in an ordinary nuisance direction, fails injection recovery or is unsupported outside training/calibration data.", "new_run_ids": [ "20260927T015444724011Z-E14" ], "new_computations_in_this_handoff": false, "permitted_article_language": "The parcel's composition response lies in its density nuisance direction. No observed signal or full observational inference exists.", "inherited_status": "unresolved_no_new_observational_fit", "pilot_scope_note": "Run links concern component checks only; the claim may remain unresolved." }, { "id": "C15", "statement": "A localized or oscillatory field configuration can provide the alternative persistence mechanism.", "status": "optional_model_family_M4_not_implemented", "scope": "Canonical and noncanonical theories must remain distinct. Long-lived numerical oscillations are not automatically biological-scale persistence.", "evidence": [], "sources": [ "S34" ], "experiments": [ "E13", "E05", "E09", "E12", "E14" ], "strengthen": "Reproduce a specified configuration with converged radiation losses, lifetime, matter coupling and environmental constraints.", "weaken": "Boundary reflections create the apparent persistence, decay is too rapid, or the chosen kinetic theory is unstable or outside its validity domain.", "new_run_ids": [], "new_computations_in_this_handoff": false, "permitted_article_language": "Oscillatory persistence is an optional different hypothesis class.", "inherited_status": "optional_model_family_M4_not_implemented", "pilot_scope_note": "Run links concern component checks only; the claim may remain unresolved." } ], "revision_utc": "2026-09-27T02:33:45.017956+00:00" }